TaxAdvisors

VAT

VAT on Real Estate in the UAE

Which UAE property supplies carry 5%, which are zero-rated and which are exempt — plus the Regulation condition behind each, and VAT on agent commission.

vat on real estate uae

UAE real estate is taxed by what is supplied, not by who supplies it. Commercial property is standard-rated at 5%. The first supply of a residential building within three years of completion is zero-rated, and every later sale or lease of it is exempt. Bare land is exempt, land that is covered is standard-rated, and an agent's commission is always 5%.

Basis: Federal Tax Authority

Commercial property, sale or lease
5%

Articles 2 and 3, Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017

First supply of a residential building
0%, within 3 years of completion

Article 45(9), Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017

Every later supply of that residential building
Exempt

Article 46(2), Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017

Condition on the residential exemption
Lease of more than 6 months, or a tenant holding an ICP ID card

Article 43(1), Cabinet Decision No. 52 of 2017 as amended

Bare land
Exempt — land covered by completed or partially completed buildings or civil engineering works is 5%

Article 46(3) of the Decree-Law, read with Article 44 of the Executive Regulation

Estate agent's or broker's commission
5%, wherever the property sits in the UAE

Article 30(7) of the Decree-Law and Article 21(3)(d) of the Executive Regulation

Retention of real estate records
15 years after the end of the tax period

Article 71(2), Cabinet Decision No. 52 of 2017 as amended

Capital Asset Scheme for a building
AED 5,000,000 or more, monitored over 10 years

Articles 57(1)(a) and 58(1), Cabinet Decision No. 52 of 2017 as amended

The FTA's real estate guide
VATGRE1, issued 19 April 2021

Federal Tax Authority, Guides, References & Public Clarifications listing, read 17 August 2026

#What is being supplied decides the rate, not who supplies it

Every real estate question in the UAE resolves to the same three-step test: what is the thing being supplied, what is being done with it, and is this the first time it has been supplied. The identity of the seller — developer, investor, individual landlord, free zone company — changes almost nothing.

That is why the same building can carry three different treatments in three years. A tower completed in January is zero-rated on its first sale, exempt on the resale two years later, and standard-rated on the service charges throughout. And it is why a single plot can flip from exempt to standard-rated the moment a contractor pours something more than foundations onto it.

The table below is the whole matrix, with the provision that actually decides each line. Everything after it is the condition attached to that line — because in UAE VAT, the rate is never the hard part; the condition is.

UAE VAT treatment by type of real estate supply, with the deciding provision
SupplyTreatmentWhere the condition sits
Commercial building, sale or lease5%Articles 2 and 3, VAT Law
First supply of a residential building within 3 years of completion0%Article 45(9), VAT Law
Any later sale or lease of that residential buildingExemptArticle 46(2), VAT Law; Article 43, Executive Regulation
First supply of a building converted from non-residential to residential0%Article 45(11), VAT Law; Article 39, Executive Regulation
Bare landExemptArticle 46(3), VAT Law; Article 44, Executive Regulation
Land covered by completed or partially completed buildings or civil engineering works5%Article 44, Executive Regulation, read with Article 46(3)
First supply of a building specifically designed for a Charity0%Article 45(10), VAT Law; Article 38, Executive Regulation
Service charges for communal areas, residential or commercial5%FTA Real Estate Guide VATGRE1, section 3.4
Estate agency, brokerage or property management commission5%Article 30(7), VAT Law; Article 21(3)(d), Executive Regulation

#Residential property: a three-year window, then exemption with its own condition

Article 45(9) of the VAT Law zero-rates the first supply of a residential building within three years of its completion, by sale or by lease, in whole or in part. Article 46(2) then exempts every supply of a residential building that is not zero-rated under Article 45(9) or 45(11). One window at 0%, exempt for the rest of the building's life.

Completion starts the clock and the Regulation does not define it, so fix that date in writing before pricing anything. The full clause-by-clause treatment of Article 45, including how it interacts with the rest of the zero-rated list, sits on the zero-rated supplies page; what follows here is the part that decides real property deals.

What the Regulation counts as residential — and the four exclusions

Article 37 of the Executive Regulation defines a residential building as one intended and designed for human occupation, including a person's principal place of residence, accommodation for students or school pupils, accommodation for armed forces and police, and orphanages, nursing homes and rest homes. Article 37(3) keeps the status where a small proportion is used as an office or workspace by the occupants, and includes garages and gardens used with it.

Article 37(2) then excludes four things outright: anything not fixed to the ground that can be moved without damage; a building used as a hotel, motel, bed and breakfast or hospital or the like; a hotel apartment or serviced apartment or the like; and any building constructed or converted without lawful authority. That last exclusion is the one that costs money quietly — an unpermitted conversion is not a residential building for VAT, however residential it looks and however it is marketed.

Converted buildings carry two tests, not one

Article 45(11) zero-rates the first supply of a building converted from non-residential to residential, and Article 39(1) of the Executive Regulation attaches two conditions to it. The supply must take place within three years of the completion of the conversion, and the original building, or any part of it, must not have been used as a residential building or have formed part of one in the five years before the conversion work started. Article 39(2) adds that shared or common facilities, dividing walls and similar features do not by themselves make the converted space part of a pre-existing residential building. A project that fails the five-year test is not zero-rated no matter how complete the conversion.

The exemption is not automatic either — it needs six months or an ID card

Article 43(1) of the Executive Regulation exempts a supply of residential buildings that is not zero-rated only where the lease is for more than six months, or the tenant holds an ID card issued by the Federal Authority for Identity and Citizenship. Article 43(2) measures the period on the contractual tenancy and ignores any right or option to extend or renew; Article 43(3) ignores a right to terminate early. A short let of a few weeks to a tenant without that ID card therefore falls outside the exemption — and a landlord relying on "residential is exempt" as a slogan has not read the condition.

Off-plan purchases

The FTA's real estate guide treats a purchase off plan, direct from the developer before construction, or of a partly completed residential building, as zero-rated — as a future supply of a residential building, assuming the property will meet the residential conditions on completion (VATGRE1, section 3.7). Where instalments run across the build, the date of supply for a contract with periodic payments or consecutive invoices is set by Article 26(1) of the Decree-Law: the earliest of the tax invoice date, the due date shown on it, or the date payment is received, with a backstop 12 months after the goods or services were provided.

#Commercial property: 5%, and the payment step that gates the transfer

Commercial real estate — offices, retail, warehousing, industrial — is a taxable supply at the standard 5% rate under Articles 2 and 3 of the VAT Law, on both sale and lease. There is no first-supply concession and no threshold below which a commercial deal escapes: the rate follows the character of the property.

What is different about commercial sales is the payment mechanism. VATGRE1 section 6.4 sets out a special process: the buyer pays the VAT on the purchase directly to the FTA rather than to the seller, receives a Payment Transaction Number, and produces that number to the Land Department before the ownership transfer can be processed. The seller still issues a tax invoice, declares the output tax on its return in the normal way, and then enters the same amount in the adjustments column so the tax is not paid twice.

The process is narrower than most summaries suggest. Per the guide it applies only where commercial property is sold in the UAE by a supplier other than the developer of that property. It does not apply to sales or leases of residential property, to leases of commercial property, to sales by the developer, or to the sale of a tenanted property to a taxable buyer where the deal qualifies as the transfer of a business.

That last exclusion is Article 7(2) of the Decree-Law: the transfer of the whole or an independent part of a business to a taxable person, for the purpose of continuing that business, is not a supply at all. A let commercial building sold with its tenancies attached is the textbook case, and getting it wrong in either direction — charging 5% on a genuine transfer of a business, or not charging it on a bare asset sale — is expensive.

#Bare land, covered land, and where the line between them falls

Article 46(3) of the VAT Law exempts the supply of bare land. Article 44 of the Executive Regulation defines bare land as land that is not covered by completed or partially completed buildings or civil engineering works. Land that fails that definition is not a special category — it simply falls outside the exemption and is standard-rated at 5%.

The FTA guide puts numbers on the boundary in a way the Regulation does not. Construction is treated as a partially completed building once it has progressed beyond foundation level; a plot where work has started but has not passed foundations is not yet covered by a partially completed building (VATGRE1, section 5.3). Fencing a plot and placing temporary movable structures on it does not make the land covered.

Civil engineering works are roads, bridges and mains water or power pipes, complete or partially complete. Section 5.4 of the guide draws the line at the surface: pipes running underneath land that do not break the surface and give that plot no right of connection leave the land bare, while pipes protruding above the surface to allow a future development to connect to mains services make the land covered, and therefore standard-rated.

There is no monetary de minimis anywhere in this. The exemption turns on the physical character of the land, not on the size of the deal or the identity of the buyer.

#Commission: the agent's fee is a separate supply, taxed at 5%

A brokerage commission is not part of the price of the property. It is a separate supply of services by the agent, and it is standard-rated at 5% whether the underlying property supply is standard-rated, zero-rated or exempt. An exempt residential resale still generates a taxable commission — and because the sale is exempt, the seller generally cannot recover that 5% as input tax, so it is a cost of the transaction rather than a wash.

Where the property sits decides where the commission is taxed. Article 30(7) of the Decree-Law places the supply of services related to real estate where the real estate is located, and Article 21 of the Executive Regulation says what counts: services directly connected with real estate, or the grant of a right to use it. Article 21(3)(d) names services by real estate experts or estate agents on that list, alongside the grant, assignment or surrender of an interest in or right over real estate, licences to occupy, and the preparation, coordination and performance of construction, demolition, maintenance and conversion work. An agent abroad who brokers a Dubai building is supplying a service in the UAE.

Not everything an agency does falls inside that rule. VATGRE1 section 11.2 lists services that are not directly related to real estate: advice or information about property markets generally, drawing plans for a building not tied to a specific site, management of a property investment portfolio, advertising including billboards, secondment of staff to a site, and general legal advice on real estate contracts. Those follow the ordinary place-of-supply rules in Articles 29 and 30 instead, which can put them outside UAE VAT when the customer is abroad. Where a land-related service is bundled with services that are not, the guide requires you to decide whether there is one composite supply or several — and to treat each accordingly.

An agent can only charge VAT if it is registered. Registration is mandatory under Article 13(1) once taxable supplies exceeded AED 375,000 over the previous 12 months, or are expected to exceed it in the next 30 days. A commission invoice showing 5% but no TRN is a claim worth verifying before you pay it.

#Landlord and tenant payments that are supplies in their own right

Ordinary landlord and tenant housekeeping generates supplies that are taxed on their own terms, regardless of whether the building is residential or commercial. The FTA's guide devotes section 10 to them, and the pattern is consistent: where one party pays the other to do something, the doing is a supply.

Where a landlord pays a prospective tenant an inducement to enter a lease, the tenant is making a supply of agreeing to enter the contract, standard-rated at 5% if the tenant is VAT registered and outside the scope if it is not. Where a landlord pays a tenant to surrender a lease early, the tenant is again making a 5% supply — the guide is explicit that this holds whether the property is commercial or residential. Consideration for varying a lease is likewise taxable at 5%, and a fundamental variation such as extending the term or changing the demised area is treated as a surrender of the old lease and the grant of a new one.

A rent-free period given for nothing in return is normally not a supply. A rent-free period given in exchange for something — the tenant refurbishing the premises, for example — is a barter, and both legs are valued equally even though they may carry different VAT treatments. Dilapidation payments split on their contractual character: paid as damages for breach they may be outside the scope, but where they are consideration for repairs the tenant should have carried out and the landlord will now do, they are standard-rated.

Service charges and owners' associations

Service charges levied for maintaining and running communal areas are standard-rated at 5%, including on residential buildings. Section 3.4 of the guide is explicit that such charges are not consideration for the supply of a residential building, so they are neither zero-rated nor exempt — a point that regularly surprises residential landlords who assume the whole relationship is exempt.

An owners' association or management entity is a person for VAT purposes and must register once its supplies exceed the registration threshold, on the same tests as any other business (VATGRE1, section 8.2). Where it registers, its service charges carry 5% and it recovers the VAT on what it buys in to maintain the building (section 8.3). The economics are usually neutral for a commercial occupier and a real cost for a residential one.

#Non-resident landlords, and property inside a Designated Zone

A landlord with no place of residence in the UAE gets no registration threshold. Article 13(2) of the Decree-Law requires every person without a place of residence in the State or an Implementing State to register where they make supplies of goods or services and no other person is obliged to pay the due tax on them. Renting out a single UAE commercial unit from abroad can therefore create a registration obligation from the first dirham.

The reverse charge does not rescue that position. VATGRE1 section 11.3 explains why: a supply of real estate is a supply of goods, the property is already in the UAE and cannot be imported, and the reverse charge addresses imported concerned goods and services from non-resident suppliers. If the property itself, with sufficient human and technical resource, amounts to a fixed establishment, the landlord is treated as resident instead — with the ordinary threshold and access to a tax group.

Designated Zones are the other special case, and they cut both ways. The guide, following VATG203, treats sales and leases of real estate located within a Designated Zone as outside the scope of VAT, subject to the conditions applying to supplies of goods in those zones. But supplies of services related to that same real estate — licences to occupy, hotel accommodation, estate agency, construction — are standard-rated at 5% even inside the zone. The zones themselves are listed in Cabinet Decision No. 59 of 2017; a free zone address is not by itself a Designated Zone.

#Recovering input tax: apportionment, the first lease, and the Capital Asset Scheme

Real estate is where input tax recovery stops being arithmetic. A developer building residential stock to sell within three years is making zero-rated supplies and recovers in full. The same developer holding the stock and letting it after the first supply is making exempt supplies and recovers nothing on those costs. A mixed-use scheme does both at once, and the residual costs have to be apportioned under Article 55 of the Executive Regulation — a percentage computed on input tax, not on turnover, rounded to a whole number, with an annual wash-up.

One provision protects developers who let rather than sell, and it is worth pinning to the wall. Article 52(4) of the Executive Regulation: where a taxable person's first supply of a residential building is by way of a zero-rated lease, that person may recover input tax in full in respect of that supply, regardless of any future intention to make later exempt supplies of that building. Without it, the construction cost would be argued into the exempt rent that follows.

Buildings then fall into the Capital Asset Scheme. Article 57(1)(a) of the Regulation makes a single item of expenditure of AED 5,000,000 or more, excluding tax, with a useful life of at least ten years, a capital asset where it is a building or part of one; five years applies to everything else. Article 57(3) aggregates staged payments for the purchase, construction, extension, refurbishment or fit-out of a building into one item, so a scheme paid in instalments does not escape by being small each month. Article 58 then requires the input tax to be monitored and adjusted over ten consecutive years for buildings, starting when the owner first uses the asset in the business, with a capital asset register kept for the purpose and the scheme ceasing in the tax year the asset is sold or destroyed.

#Records on a property must be kept for fifteen years

Article 71(2) of the Executive Regulation requires any records related to real estate to be held for 15 years after the end of the tax period to which they relate. That is the longest retention clock in UAE tax law, and it is routinely reported as five or seven years because those are the general figures elsewhere: the Tax Procedures Executive Regulation sets five years as the base with seven for real estate records, and the Corporate Tax Law sets seven years after the tax period. For VAT purposes on a property, the fifteen-year rule in Article 71(2) governs.

In practice the clock outlives the building's first owner, the agent who sold it and often the accounting system that produced the invoices. Completion certificates, the evidence fixing the date of completion, tenancy contracts, the ID card evidence supporting the Article 43 exemption, and the capital asset register all sit inside it. Failing to keep records is a published penalty of AED 10,000 per violation, rising to AED 20,000 for a repeat within 24 months.

#goAML registration for real estate brokers and agents

goAML has nothing to do with VAT, and real estate agencies keep discovering the two obligations at the same moment. Article 3(2) of Cabinet Decision No. 134 of 2025 — the Executive Regulation of Federal Decree-Law No. 10 of 2025 — lists real estate brokers and agents, when concluding transactions or settlements on behalf of their customers in relation to the purchase or sale of real estate, as a Designated Non-Financial Business and Profession. That designation carries the full AML programme: registration on goAML, a compliance officer, customer due diligence, screening, suspicious transaction reporting and record keeping.

Note what the clause does not contain. There is no monetary threshold on the designation for real estate brokers and agents; the AED 55,000 figure in the same article belongs to dealers in precious metals and stones. The Ministry of Economy and Tourism's Guidelines for Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions of March 2026 do use AED 55,000 as the point at which an occasional transaction — a one-off deal for a customer with no ongoing relationship — triggers customer due diligence, and require due diligence at any value where there is a suspicion. Registration itself is not optional above or below any number.

The Ministry supervises real estate agents and brokers directly, alongside dealers in precious metals and stones, independent accountants and auditors, and corporate service providers. Registration is a separate exercise from VAT registration, on a separate portal, with separate penalties.

#The FTA's own guide, how far it can be relied on, and what this page will not state

There is one FTA guide dedicated to this subject: VAT Guide | Real Estate | VATGRE1, issued 19 April 2021. It was still listed under current VAT Guides, not under Archive VAT Guides, when the Authority's guides listing was read on 17 August 2026. It is issued under Article 73 of the Executive Regulation and states on its face that it is not legally binding on the FTA.

Read it with its date in mind. It predates Federal Decree-Law No. 18 of 2022, Federal Decree-Law No. 16 of 2024 and Federal Decree-Law No. 16 of 2025 on the Law side, and Cabinet Decision No. 100 of 2024 and Cabinet Decision No. 100 of 2025 on the Regulation side. The serviced-apartment divergence noted above is one concrete example of what that gap looks like. Where the guide and the current consolidated texts differ, the legislation governs; the guide remains useful for the process detail and worked positions that the legislation never sets out, such as the commercial property payment route and the boundary tests for covered land.

One related scheme has its own current guide. A UAE national who builds a residence for themselves or their family may reclaim the VAT on construction: the request must reach the FTA within 12 months from the date the residence is completed — the earlier of occupation, certification of completion by a competent UAE authority, or a date stipulated by the FTA — with retention payments claimable within six months of payment (VATGRH1, 9 June 2026).

What this page will not tell you

It will not tell you that a named development, tower or developer is zero-rated or exempt. The treatment attaches to the supply and its date, not to a brand, and nobody can price your unit from its address — verify the completion date and the supply history for the specific unit.

It will not quote a property price, a transfer fee, or any Dubai Land Department or municipality charge. Those are not FTA figures and none of them were read from the land department's own current schedule, so publishing them here would be a guess dressed as guidance. Ask the relevant land department directly, in writing, before you budget.

And it makes no claim about this firm's own record, clients or results. Where a transaction is large enough that the difference between zero-rated and exempt matters, the Authority's own clarification route exists for exactly that question.

Sources and legal basis

This page relies on

  • Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017 on Value Added Tax (consolidated to 28 November 2025)
  • Federal Decree-Law No. 16 of 2025 (amendment to the VAT Law, in force 1 January 2026)
  • Cabinet Decision No. 52 of 2017 (Executive Regulation of the VAT Law, consolidated to 18 September 2025)
  • Cabinet Decision No. 100 of 2024 (amendment to the VAT Executive Regulation)
  • Cabinet Decision No. 100 of 2025 (amendment to the VAT Executive Regulation)
  • Article 3 of the VAT Law (5% standard rate)
  • Article 7(2) of the VAT Law (transfer of a whole or independent part of a Business is not a supply)
  • Article 13(1) and 13(2) of the VAT Law (mandatory registration, and non-residents with no threshold)
  • Article 26(1) of the VAT Law (date of supply for periodic payments and consecutive invoices)
  • Article 30(7) of the VAT Law (place of supply of services related to real estate)
  • Article 45(9) of the VAT Law (first supply of residential buildings within 3 years of completion)
  • Article 45(10) and 45(11) of the VAT Law (charitable buildings, and converted residential buildings)
  • Article 46(2) and 46(3) of the VAT Law (exempt residential supplies and bare land)
  • Executive Regulation Article 21 (place of supply of services related to real estate, including estate agents)
  • Executive Regulation Article 37 (residential buildings, and the four exclusions)
  • Executive Regulation Article 39 (zero-rating a converted residential building)
  • Executive Regulation Article 43 (exemption of residential buildings: six months or an ICP ID card)
  • Executive Regulation Article 44 (bare land)
  • Executive Regulation Article 52(4) (full recovery on a zero-rated first lease)
  • Executive Regulation Article 55 (apportionment of input tax)
  • Executive Regulation Articles 57 and 58 (Capital Asset Scheme, AED 5,000,000 and 10 years for buildings)
  • Executive Regulation Article 71(2) (15-year retention for real estate records)
  • VAT Guide | Real Estate | VATGRE1, Federal Tax Authority, 19 April 2021
  • VAT Guide | Refund for UAE Nationals Building New Residences | VATGRH1, 9 June 2026
  • Cabinet Decision No. 59 of 2017 on Designated Zones
  • Federal Decree-Law No. 10 of 2025 on Anti-Money Laundering
  • Cabinet Decision No. 134 of 2025 (Executive Regulation of the AML Decree-Law)
  • Ministry of Economy and Tourism Guidelines for Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions, March 2026
  • Federal Authority for Identity and Citizenship (ICP)
  • Mandatory registration threshold of AED 375,000
  1. Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017 on Value Added Tax and its amendments, consolidated text published 28 November 2025Federal Tax Authority
  2. Executive Regulation of Federal Decree-Law No. 8 of 2017, consolidated text published 18 September 2025Federal Tax Authority
  3. VAT Guide | Real Estate | VATGRE1, issued 19 April 2021Federal Tax Authority
  4. VAT Guide | Refund for UAE Nationals Building New Residences | VATGRH1, 9 June 2026Federal Tax Authority
  5. Guides, References & Public Clarifications — the listing where VATGRE1 is publishedFederal Tax Authority
  6. VAT legislation index — the current consolidated Law and Executive RegulationFederal Tax Authority
  7. Cabinet Decision No. 134 of 2025 — Executive Regulation of Federal Decree-Law No. 10 of 2025 (DNFBP designation, Article 3)UAE Financial Intelligence Unit
  8. Guidelines for Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions, March 2026Ministry of Economy and Tourism

Rates, thresholds and deadlines change. Every figure above is linked to the authority that publishes it — if the two ever disagree, the authority is right and this page is out of date. Tell us and we will fix it.

FAQ Answers to the questions people actually ask

Frequently asked questions

Is there VAT on real estate in Dubai?

Yes, on some supplies and not others, and Dubai follows the federal rules with no emirate-level variation. Commercial property carries 5% on sale and lease. The first supply of a residential building within three years of completion is zero-rated, and later sales and leases of it are exempt. Bare land is exempt; land covered by buildings or civil engineering works is 5%.

Is VAT chargeable on sale of land?

Only where the land is not bare. Article 46(3) of the VAT Law exempts the supply of bare land, and Article 44 of the Executive Regulation defines bare land as land not covered by completed or partially completed buildings or civil engineering works. Land carrying roads, mains pipes that break the surface, or construction past foundation level is standard-rated at 5%.

What is exempted from VAT in the UAE?

Article 46 of the VAT Law exempts four categories: specified financial services, supplies of residential buildings by sale or lease other than those zero-rated under Article 45, bare land, and local passenger transport. The residential exemption carries its own condition — the lease must exceed six months, or the tenant must hold an ID card issued by the Federal Authority for Identity and Citizenship.

What is the minimum VAT exemption for selling property?

There is none. No monetary threshold exempts a property sale in the UAE: the treatment depends on what is sold and when, not on the price. The AED 375,000 figure often quoted is the mandatory VAT registration threshold for a business, not a property exemption, and it has no application to whether a particular sale is standard-rated, zero-rated or exempt.

Is VAT charged on real estate commission in the UAE?

Yes, at 5%, regardless of how the underlying property is treated. A commission is a separate supply of services by the agent, and Article 21(3)(d) of the Executive Regulation names services by real estate experts and estate agents as directly connected with real estate, so Article 30(7) places the supply where the property is. On an exempt residential resale the seller usually cannot recover that VAT.

Do real estate brokers need to register on goAML?

Yes. Article 3(2) of Cabinet Decision No. 134 of 2025 designates real estate brokers and agents concluding transactions or settlements for customers on the purchase or sale of real estate as a Designated Non-Financial Business and Profession, supervised by the Ministry of Economy and Tourism. No monetary threshold applies to that designation, and goAML registration is entirely separate from VAT registration.

Next

Continue reading

Ask

Have a question this page did not answer?

This is where a question goes once the channel is open. It is not open yet, so there is no form here to type one into — see the note opposite.

Not open yet

There is nowhere for this to send

No enquiry address has been set up for this site, so a form here would take your question, your name and your email and throw them away while telling you they had arrived. Rather than do that, it is switched off.

When it opens, what is promised is a written answer citing the instrument it rests on, and no phone number will be asked for. Until then the pages are the answer: every one names its sources and links them.